Calling nested functions inside a parfor loop

11 views (last 30 days)
Hello,
I am trying to parallelize a program. I am experiencing issues with a parallel for and nested functions. My main function contains a big parfor loop, and several nested functions. These nested function access (both read and write) the variables declared in the main function. Without parallelism, everything works fine: my nested function do their job and update the variables in my main function (as it is supposed to be). This is true whether I call the nested function directly or using a handle. However, when I switch to a parfor (and thus use handles, as it should be), and make so that no error appear, the nested function no longer updates the variables from the main function. Said otherwise, MATLAB does not detect any error, but my program doesn't really do anything!
Below is a representative example:
function garbage
accumulator = [];
handleFoo = @foo;
for i=1:10
aux = i*5;
handleFoo(aux);
end
accumulator
function foo(n)
accumulator(end+1) = n;
end
end
Running this program as-is will result "accumulator" equal to 1:10. But simply changing the for loop to a parfor will resut in an empty array.
Is this the expected behavior of MATLAB? Is there away to work around this? I could not find help on this specific question anywhere.
Thank you Antoine

Accepted Answer

Edric Ellis
Edric Ellis on 16 Mar 2015
Yes, this is expected behaviour - the MATLAB workers operating on the body of your parfor loop are separate MATLAB processes, and they do not share thing like handle variables, or nested function workspaces. All data that flows into and out from a parfor loop must go through explicit variable transfers.
  2 Comments
Antoine GUELLIER
Antoine GUELLIER on 16 Mar 2015
Edited: Antoine GUELLIER on 16 Mar 2015
Thank you! I supposed it was this way, but I didn't see this fact explicited anywhere.
Hung Dao
Hung Dao on 6 Jul 2021
Is there a solution for this? I am having a similar issue. I want to call a function f inside a parfor loop. I am using feval(f, arguments of f). The function f calls another functions. Without parfor, it works OK but with parfor it results in an error.

Sign in to comment.

More Answers (0)

Categories

Find more on Parallel for-Loops (parfor) in Help Center and File Exchange

Products

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!