Normxcorr2 and xcorr2
54 views (last 30 days)
Show older comments
Hi
I'm trying to perform a 2D autocorrelation using the two functions. The problem is that I am getting different results using the seemingly same functions. The help document although mentions that Normxcorr2 requires the size of the image to be larger than the template. Does this mean that normxcorr2 doesn't work for autocorrelation and returns incorrect results? I don't understand how a correlation function cannot work for autocorrelation. I need a normalized 2D autocorrelation and Normxcorr2 is getting me really confused. Any help will be really appreciated.
1 Comment
RITIKA MALIK
on 30 Jun 2022
https://in.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/answers/95436-why-are-my-results-different-in-xcorr2-and-normxcorr2-in-matlab-7-7-r2008b#answer_104789
Answers (2)
David Young
on 29 Nov 2011
The functions are not the same: normxcorr2 normalises (i.e. divides by the product of the local standard deviations) but xcorr2 does not.
EDIT: add
In addition, normxcorr2 subtracts the mean of the template before performing the multiplications. This changes the results greatly - for example, it can easily change the sign of some of the values. On top of this, when the functions are used for autocorrelation calculations, mean removal interacts with zero-padding of the arrays to change the results in quite hard-to-understand ways.
All the same, there's no question of normxcorr2 being unreliable. It just implements a different function to xcorr2. Which one of them does autocorrelation depends on how you define autocorrelation.
What you have to do is decide exactly what you want to compute and compare it to the equations given in the documentation for the functions. The terminology round autocorrelation/autocovariance isn't used consistently, so it is essential to look at the equations.
2 Comments
David Young
on 30 Nov 2011
Yes, there are other differences too. I'll edit my answer rather than putting them in a comment.
Dirk Padfield
on 26 Dec 2013
This is exactly the same problem I noticed with normxcorr2, and this was the reason I contributed the following file
Hopefully this helps solve your issue.
0 Comments
See Also
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!