MATLAB Answers


Question about Kmeans function

Asked by zheng
on 10 Mar 2011
Latest activity Commented on by Vladimir Borgiani on 29 Dec 2015

Anyone can explain this, please?

[IDX,C] = kmeans(X,k,param1,val1)

here, 'start' is as param1, Matrix is as val. It is the method used to choose the initial cluster centroid positions.

Matlab help exaplained as: "k-by-p matrix of centroid starting locations. In this case, you can pass in [] for k, and kmeans infers k from the first dimension of the matrix."

Here is function I try to use: [IDX,C]=kmeans(data,[],'Distance','sqEuclidean','emptyaction','singleton','Start',data);

Question 1: is "data" that Matrix which help talked about? Question 2: if it is, the new problem coming as below "??? Error using ==> NaN Out of memory. Type HELP MEMORY for your options.

Error in ==> kmeans at 298 if online, Del = NaN(n,k); end % reassignment criterion"

In my case, dimension of data is 334795x2.


4 Answers

Answer by Matt Tearle
on 23 Mar 2011
 Accepted answer

The 'start' parameter defines the initial centroid locations. As the help explains, it should be k-by-p where k is the number of groups you're splitting the data into. If you use the data matrix itself, then k is the same as the number of data points! That is, your asking kmeans to group n points into n groups! The result will be that each data point is in its own group. If you have 300,000 points, you'll also run out of memory, it seems.

This is what you're trying to do:

X = rand(20,2);
g = kmeans(X,[],'start',X)

This is what you should be doing:

g = kmeans(X,[],'start',[0.25,0.75;0.25,0.25;0.75,0.25;0.75,0.75])

Note that the data (X) is 20-by-2. The starting matrix is 4-by-2, so kmeans makes 4 groups out of the 20 points.

  1 Comment

Is there any way to run K-means to discover the best centroids but using the inputs instead of calculating the best centroid? Example, we supply a matrix with positions X and Y and instruct k-means to find the N best centroids as long as they are existent locations.

Answer by zheng
on 17 Mar 2011

Well, still be confused about above, please someone help me


Answer by Tom Lane
on 31 Mar 2011

You have written


You don't want to specify "data" as both the input data and the starting guess at the centroid locations. Suppose you want kmeans with k=7. You want the 'Start' value to have 7 rows, one for each centroid.


Answer by Elad
on 5 Jul 2013

Check out the color reduction using kmeans example here:


Join the 15-year community celebration.

Play games and win prizes!

Learn more
Discover MakerZone

MATLAB and Simulink resources for Arduino, LEGO, and Raspberry Pi

Learn more

Discover what MATLAB® can do for your career.

Opportunities for recent engineering grads.

Apply Today

MATLAB Academy

New to MATLAB?

Learn MATLAB today!