MATLAB Answers

Matt J

How do multiple Answers in a post get Accepted?

Asked by Matt J
on 20 Dec 2012
Accepted Answer by Matt J

What situations allow multiple Answers in a thread (less than a week old) to get Accept-clicked, as seems to have occurred here:

http://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/answers/57092-finding-a-noninteger-value-from-an-array

  5 Comments

Randy Souza
on 20 Dec 2012

I'm going to set Matt's answer as the accepted one, because: (1) it was posted earlier (by two whole minutes), (2) according to the database it was accepted earlier, and (3) because the answer code is the same.

However, Kye keeps the 4 reputation points earned for an accepted answer.

Kye Taylor
on 20 Dec 2012

We should both get the points for our rep, and extra points for finding the bug!

Matt J
on 20 Dec 2012

@Kye - if you convert your comment to an Answer, I'll upvote it and you will get extra points! You can do the same for me by upvoting the question ;)

Products

No products are associated with this question.

3 Answers

Matt J
Answer by Matt J
on 4 Jan 2013
 Accepted answer

Just closing this.

  0 Comments


Answer by Kye Taylor
on 20 Dec 2012

Hahaha thanks @Matt J...

Extra +1 to us for stumbling on the bug!

  0 Comments


Answer by Image Analyst
on 20 Dec 2012

I wonder is Randy is experimenting with the ability to "Unanswer" a question and mark the better one as the "Answer" - something a lot of people have been asking for for a long time, though I suspect he tries this stuff out first on a sandbox, non-production copy of the database rather than the production one.

  2 Comments

Randy Souza
on 20 Dec 2012

No, we're still considering the accept-a-different-answer use case, but haven't started on the random experimentation yet :-)

Image Analyst
on 21 Apr 2013

It looks like multiple answers can now be done. Have you added that capability? For example I saw it in this posting. Though only one of the "Answerers" is listed on the main topic view.


Discover what MATLAB® can do for your career.

Opportunities for recent engineering grads.

Apply today