Asked by Michael Bernard
on 4 Feb 2013

Hi everyone, its not serious problem at all. But I just want to know. Why cant Matlab calculate a(0) in a for loop.

Example: n=3;L=4;

>> ai=[2 4 6 8]; for m=0:n an(m)=-ai(L-m)/ai(1) end

Matlab will give an error message that says

"Attempted to access (0); index must be a positive integer or logical."

My question is why?? I get results if I use

for m=1:n an(m)=-ai(L-m)/ai(1) end

because a(1) , a(2) etc can be found in matlab. so why not a(0)???

*No products are associated with this question.*

Answer by Azzi Abdelmalek
on 4 Feb 2013

Edited by Azzi Abdelmalek
on 4 Feb 2013

Accepted answer

It's just how Matlab works, allows only positive integer or logical index. You can resolve the problem, for example

for k=0:10 y(k+1)=sin(k) end

Answer by Walter Roberson
on 4 Feb 2013

You need to distinguish between array notation and function notation.

Array notation requires that the arguments describe integer array locations. Array locations in MATLAB are numbered starting from 1, as is the case for Fortran and a number of other computer languages (but not all -- e.g., C numbers starting from 0.)

function notation is what is used when you say things like

f(1.37) = 8.2

or

an(0) = 4

That notation is completely valid in mathematics, but it has no equivalent in MATLAB, except inside MuPAD (the symbolic toolbox).

Opportunities for recent engineering grads.

## 0 Comments