MATLAB Answers


Using find with a vector without having to use a for loop

Asked by Matlab2010
on 14 Mar 2013

I have code which does

for t = 1: length(vector2)
    idx(t) = find(vector <=vector2(t), 1, 'last');

Can I call find.m without using a for loop (or bsxfun.m) and if so how?

Or should I just use histc?

[~,idx]=histc(vector2, vector);


on 14 Mar 2013

That is not true! BSXFUN is highly parallized under the hood. Fastest function you can get.

Jan Simon
on 14 Mar 2013

BSXFUN is not a slower version of a loop. I think ARRAYFUN could earn this description, especially when used with anonymous functions.

on 28 Mar 2013

Having read more about this, I accept my previous statement is wrong and I was getting bsxfun confused with arrayfun.

it seems like bsxfun is what I need. thank you!



No products are associated with this question.

1 Answer

Answer by Friedrich
on 14 Mar 2013
Edited by Friedrich
on 14 Mar 2013
 Accepted answer


use bsxfun and make sure one vector is a row vector and the other a column vector (a would be vector and b would be vector2)

 a = [1 2 3 4 5 6]
 b = [ 1 5 8 3 -10 2]
 idx = bsxfun(@le,a',b)

Now you need to get a bit tricky I guess:

 tmp = idx*(10.^[1:numel(b)]')

Not sure if maybe log2 would be faster, you would need to try it:

   tmp = idx*(2.^[1:numel(b)]')


Jan Simon
on 14 Mar 2013

POWER and LOG10 are expensive functions. There must be a solution based on the integer indices also.

Jan Simon
on 14 Mar 2013

Yes! When the input vector2 (as in the original question) is sorted (and find(., 1, 'last') implies that it is), the logical matrix created by bsxfun contains zeros on the left and ones on the right (or top and bottom?). Then this matrix can be reshaped to a row vector and strfind searchs for [false true]. Finally the resulting indices must be cleaned up using mod() with the number of columns.

Discover what MATLAB® can do for your career.

Opportunities for recent engineering grads.

Apply today