MATLAB Answers

Eli

how do I vectorize a loop with multi-dimensional arrays/ outer product

Asked by Eli
on 21 Jun 2013

Hi, would someone happen to know how I could vectorize the following loop?

      L=4;
      for t=1:N;
        A(:,:,t)=exp(a*(t-1)).*B(:,:,L);
      end

many thanks, Eli

  2 Comments

James Tursa
on 21 Jun 2013

Is "a" a scalar?

Eli
on 21 Jun 2013

yes

2 Answers

Answer by Andrei Bobrov
on 21 Jun 2013
 Accepted answer
B1 = B(:,:,4);
out = reshape(B1(:)*(0:N-1),[size(B1) N]);

  3 Comments

Eli
on 21 Jun 2013

thanks! this works, but didn't turn out to be more efficient than the loop, I think. here is my try, did I get this right?

clear all;
N=1000;
a=rand(1,1000);
B=rand(128,256,N);
C=NaN(128,256,N);
tic 
for t=1:N
  C(:,:,t)=B(:,:,4)*a(t);
end
toc
tic
B1 = B(:,:,4);
C1 = reshape(B1(:)*a,[size(B1) N]);
toc
difference=max(max(max(abs(C1-C))))

output:

Elapsed time is 0.097027 seconds. Elapsed time is 0.110844 seconds.

difference =

     0
James Tursa
on 22 Jun 2013

Your timing is comparing apples to oranges. You preallocate the answer for your loop but do not include it in your timing, whereas you penalize the reshaped outer product by including its intrinsic allocation in the timing. Your loop timing should be this instead, which includes both the allocation and the operations:

tic 
C=NaN(128,256,N);
for t=1:N
  C(:,:,t)=B(:,:,4)*a(t);
end
toc

Also, the timings should be run several times to make sure background functions are loaded into memory (I assume you do not want the function loading times to bias your results). So don't clear all between timing runs, just clear the variables you allocate (e.g., C, B1, and C1).

Eli
on 22 Jun 2013

Brilliant of you. the vectorized version seems significantly faster now. thanks! here it is:

%clear all;
N=1000;
a=rand(1,N);
B=rand(128,256,N);
tic 
C=NaN(128,256,N);
for t=1:N
  C(:,:,t)=B(:,:,4)*a(t);
end
toc
tic
C1 = reshape(reshape(B(:,:,4),[128*256*1,1])*a,[128 256 N]);
toc
difference=max(max(max(abs(C1-C))))

output:

Elapsed time is 0.230418 seconds.

Elapsed time is 0.123938 seconds.

difference = 0


Answer by Iain
on 21 Jun 2013
Edited by Iain
on 21 Jun 2013
 A = bsxfun(@times,exp(bsxfun(@times,a,0:(t-1)),B); 

You need to make sure that a, 0:t-1 and B are all in the correct dimensions, and that "times", is the correct multiplication for your needs.

 A = bsxfun(@times,exp(bsxfun(@times,a,reshape(0:(t-1),1, 1,[]),B); 

  1 Comment

Eli
on 21 Jun 2013

thanks! I am afraid I wasn't able to make this work. here is a more specific example in the hope this clarifies what the problem was:

clear all;
N=1000;
a=rand(1,1000);
B=rand(128,256,N);
C=NaN(128,256,N);
tic 
for t=1:N
  C(:,:,t)=B(:,:,4)*a(t);
end
toc

Discover what MATLAB® can do for your career.

Opportunities for recent engineering grads.

Apply today