In our book , we proposed some stability test theorems for linear time-delay system.
To verify our stability test theorems and others' stability test algorithms , we provide this simulation program of time-delay systems.
You can use the program, to find that the results of  are incorrecct.
The following example is taken from the case 1 of , where  claimed to found a stable region for the time-delay system of case 1,however, the simulation shows that the time-delay system of case 1 is unstable,
with delay parameters: t1=.4;t2=.5; t3=.169;t4=0.26.
Thus, the main results of  are incorrect.
 Yang Xiao, Yingkang Zhang, Multidimensional Signal Processing and
Multidimensional Systems, Publishing House of Electronics Industry,
 Rifat Sipahi and Ismail Ilker Delice, Advanced Clustering With Frequency Sweeping Methodology for the Stability Analysis of Multiple Time-Delay Systems,IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON AUTOMATIC CONTROL, VOL. 56, NO. 2, 2011, pp.467-472.
Reply to the comments of Rifat Sipahi:
Most of stability test algorithms are sufficient condition for time-delay systems. To verify the conservatism of the algorithms we need some examples of time-delay systems. We are interested in the recent new stability test algorithms including your algorithm in .
However, we disappointed that  claimed to found a stable region for the time-delay system of case 1, our simulation shows that the time-delay system of case 1 is unstable in fact. It is possible for the example in  to mislead readers of IEEE Trans AC.
The numerical example in  was accidentally labeled stable as this can be trivially confirmed with TRACE DDE software. On the link
the correction is clearly mentioned.
It is questionable why  is needed to simulate time-delay systems; as multiple and world-wide established resources already exist:
Simulink toolbox can simulation LTI delay systems easily, and rightmost roots can be computed easily by the work of Dimitri Breda (and colleagues), Dirk Roose (and colleagues), Tomas Vyhlidal (and colleagues), and Galip Ulsoy (and colleagues), using respectively TRACE DDE, BIF TOOL, QPMR, and Lambert W function approaches.
Some errors in the description are corrected.
Some errors in description are corrected.
Download apps, toolboxes, and other File Exchange content using Add-On Explorer in MATLAB.