From: "Jose Matos" <jmatos120@cox.net>
Path: news.mathworks.com!newsfeed.mathworks.com!WebX
Newsgroups: comp.soft-sys.matlab
Subject: Re: Scoring Algorithm
Message-ID: <eeb4a65.61@WebX.raydaftYaTP>
Date: Tue, 12 Nov 2002 15:23:06 -0500
References: <eeb4a65.-1@WebX.raydaftYaTP> <eeb4a65.9@WebX.raydaftYaTP> <eeb4a65.10@WebX.raydaftYaTP> <eeb4a65.22@WebX.raydaftYaTP> <eeb4a65.59@WebX.raydaftYaTP>
Lines: 68
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="ISO-8859-1"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit
Xref: news.mathworks.com comp.soft-sys.matlab:142691


This is my first time participating in this contest and I have been
loving every minute of it!


I agree with Stefan's third point: to be able to submit for testing
purposes only and maybe with his first point: to consider code length.


Jose


Stefan Stoll wrote:
> 
> 
> Kevin Spiteri wrote:
>>
>> score = result + exp(-1.95 + 0.05*runtime)
>>
> 
> The current top entry contains 1771 lines
> of poorly documented M-code, making it al-
> most impossible to grasp what's being changed
> or added from one entry to the next.
> 
> I admit that all the submitted "spaghetti
> codes" are very good at folding the proteins
> from the contest suite, but I can't escape
> the feeling that most GPRs (good programming
> rules) are completely neglected. To put it
> a bit sharper:
> 
> The contest discourages good programming.
> 
> Don't misunderstand me. I am enjoying the
> contest and facinated by the zoology of
> modules in the current code!
> 
> So what can be improved?
> - Add the length of the p-code of an entry
> to its score. This will favour generic
> and compact solutions.
> - Disclose code of new entries only when
> they are a few hours old. This helps
> participants to stick to their own ideas
> at least for a while before copying the
> tweaks from others into their codes.
> - Let participants submit entries for
> testing purposes only. The scoring
> result will be sent back to the parti-
> cipant per e-mail. So one has time to
> work on an idea before it gets "open
> source". Every fifth contribution (or
> so) of a participant gets included into
> the official ranking, and its code
> disclosed.
> - If the contest should encourage team
> work, why not set up teams that can
> register and share their private ranking
> for a while? One could combine the best
> codes from all private ranking lists into
> an official ranking every couple of
> hours.
> 
> Just ideas...
> 
> Last not least:
> Please provide an entry download button in
> addition to the edit button!
> 
> sTefan
>