MATLAB Answers


symbolic differentiation with multiple variables/parameters

Asked by Ruye Wang on 7 May 2013

I use the follow code to create a sigmoid function of x with a parameter a, and its derivative with respect to x:

>>    syms a x
>>    g = 1/(1+exp(-a*x)) 
>>    dg = diff(g,x)
I then plot them with a=1:
>>    g=matlabFunction(g);
>>    dg=matlabFunction(dg);
>>    x=-10:0.01:10;
>>    plot(x,g(x,1),x,dg(x,1))
>>    subplot(1,2,1)
>>    plot(x,g(1,x),x,g(x,1))
>>    subplot(1,2,2)
>>    plot(x,dg(1,x),x,dg(x,1))

While the first plot gives two identical curves, the second one gives two different ones: dg(1,x) is right but dg(x,1) is wrong.

From these results it seems the function dg takes the first argument as a and second x, instead of the other way around. But why is it this the case? What is the general rule in terms of the order of the parameters/variables in such a function?

Thanks for the help!


Log in to comment.

1 Answer

Answer by Iman Ansari on 8 May 2013


doc matlabFunction

Help: When converting symbolic expressions, the order is alphabetical.When converting symbolic functions, the input arguments appear infront of other variables. Other variables are sorted alphabetically.

You can change it:

syms a x
g = 1/(1+exp(-a*x))
dg = diff(g,x)
g=matlabFunction(g,'vars',[x a])
dg=matlabFunction(dg,'vars',[x a])


Log in to comment.

Discover MakerZone

MATLAB and Simulink resources for Arduino, LEGO, and Raspberry Pi

Learn more

Discover what MATLAB® can do for your career.

Opportunities for recent engineering grads.

Apply Today

MATLAB Academy

New to MATLAB?

Learn MATLAB today!