# Error in splitapply command

10 views (last 30 days)
Ivan Mich on 27 Feb 2021
Commented: Image Analyst on 28 Feb 2021
I am using this command "splitapply" in order to find mean (average) of a group of data.
edges=1:0.5:10
[N, edges, bin] = histcounts(B, edges);
mean_B=splitapply(@mean, B, bin) %mean
%B is 1000x1 double
But command window shows me :
Error using splitapply (line 61)
Group numbers must be a vector of positive integers, and cannot be a sparse vector.
which is curiousness because for an another set of data code runs.

Image Analyst on 27 Feb 2021
This seems to work fine:
B = 1 + 9 * rand(1, 100000);
edges = 1 : 0.5 : 10
[counts, edges, bin] = histcounts(B, edges);
% bin says what bin the value was placed into.
% Compute the means of the values in each bin.
mean_B = splitapply(@mean, B, bin)
Attach your B so we can see why it's different than mine. If your B exceeds 10, it will say that bin is zero for those values exceeding 10, and that would be a problem since you're passing in bin as the "group number" and the group numbers have to be natural numbers (1,2,3,4,...) and not zero.
Image Analyst on 28 Feb 2021
Keep in mind that you can't delete/remove elements from a array with more than 2 dimensions because it must remain rectangular. It can't have "holes" or "ragged edges" in it. You can only remove elements from a 1-D vector.
If you have a 2-D matrix and get a map of where it's above or below some threshold, then if you pass that into the 2-D matrix as a logical index, it can't give you a 2-D matrix back with "holes" in it where the non-selected elements are missing. So it returns the elements all concatenated in a 1-D vector pulled from the original matrix in a "column major" manner.