Clear Filters
Clear Filters

overwriting certain lines in a matrix with previous lines that satisfy a condition.

2 views (last 30 days)
Hi.
I have a vector which marks rows that needs to be overwritten in a matrix.
The marked rows should be replaced with the previously row that isn't marked.
Line 1 will never be marked so no need to take account for the potential error.
The matrix is big and will always have enough rows that markedrows refers to.
Ex:
Vector: markedrows = [3,6,7,14,15,16,17] (markedrows will always be in ascending order)
So the deal is, according to markedrows, in the matrix:
  • The new line 3 should be the same as line 2
  • The new line 6 should be the same as line 5
  • The new line 7, however, shouldn't be line 6 cause line 6 is marked too, it should instead be line 5.
Following this pattern would make line 14, 15, 16 and 17 all turn into line 13.
I hope this makes sence and that you can help :).

Accepted Answer

Guillaume
Guillaume on 18 Nov 2014
Simply do:
for row = markedrows
m(row, :) = m(row-1, :);
end
row 14 is replaced by row 13, row 15 by row 14 which is now equal to row 13, etc.
  8 Comments
Guillaume
Guillaume on 18 Nov 2014
Edited: Guillaume on 18 Nov 2014
The syntax I used for the loop doesn't have a backward mode. It just goes through the columns of the vector in the order they're in. Hence, you need to fliplr the original markedrows:
markedrows = [3,6,7,14,15,16,17];
assert(max(markedrows) < size(m, 1)); %make sure you're not marking the last row.
for row = fliplr(markedrows)
m(row, :) = m(row+1, :)
end
Søren
Søren on 18 Nov 2014
I must have done a typo the first time I ran it then, it works perfectly now.
Thanks alot to both of you, you've been very helpful!

Sign in to comment.

More Answers (2)

Kelly Kearney
Kelly Kearney on 18 Nov 2014
marked = [3,6,7,14,15,16,17];
good = setdiff(1:20, marked);
prev = arrayfun(@(x) good(find(good < x,1,'last')), marked)
prev =
2 5 5 13 13 13 13
  3 Comments
Guillaume
Guillaume on 18 Nov 2014
It uses arrayfun to go through all the elements in marked. For each element in marked, it find the greatest ( last) value that is not ( setdiff) part of marked. That's the index of the row you need to use to replace each row in marked.
Kelly Kearney
Kelly Kearney on 18 Nov 2014
Guillaume's method is more efficient if you just need to replace the rows and be done with it, but if you want a record of which rows were replaced with which, this is an alternative.
And just run
m(marked,:) = m(prev,:);
to do the actual replacement.

Sign in to comment.


Andrew Reibold
Andrew Reibold on 18 Nov 2014
Edited: Andrew Reibold on 18 Nov 2014
This is not the most efficient memory-wise, but it is a working solution and I tried to use basic commands. I just made up a matrix m to demonstrate. See the comment for change that will let you increment the other direction if you want.
m = round(rand(2,20)'*10) %a random matrix of numbers 1-10
markedrows = [3,6,7,14,15,16,17];
new_m = m;
for row = 1:size(m,1)
nrow = row;
while find(markedrows == nrow);
nrow = nrow-1; %make this MINUS a PLUS to swap direction.
new_m(row,:) = m(nrow,:);
end
end
new_m %outputs to command window for comparison
  5 Comments
Søren
Søren on 18 Nov 2014
thank you very much!
Last question for you and I'm out. When I first stated that I had a big matrix it might have been abit underestimated, its huge.
While this solution works perferctly, I'm curious if there is a more suitable sulotion for a huge matrix where I dont have to loop though the entire matrix when I've allready found out which lines needs to be altered?
Andrew Reibold
Andrew Reibold on 18 Nov 2014
Edited: Andrew Reibold on 18 Nov 2014
Short answer - Yes, there are better solutions. :D
For now, go check Guillaumes solution again. I actually think his solution is superior in many ways now that I correctly realize what it is doing.
It would be WAY better for large matrices because it only spends time where necessary.

Sign in to comment.

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!