54 views (last 30 days)

The documentation for function "mvregress" states that the return value "beta" is a vector of the regression coefficients. Looking deeper into "Multivariate Normal Regression", we see that matlab uses the same regression coefficients ("beta") for every dimension of the multivariate response variable Y

This is ludicrous. Of course each component of the response variable can have its own set of coefficients. THAT is multivariate linear regression.

Am I missing something? Is this just an inherent shortcoming in matlab's "mvregress" function? If so, what a bizarre design choice...

Is there some way to get real multivariate linear regression, i.e. get a matrix beta of regression coefficients?

the cyclist
on 16 Mar 2013

Edited: the cyclist
on 16 Mar 2013

Tom Lane
on 16 Mar 2013

Just to follow up on the cyclist's answer (from my MathWorks perspective), mvregress is admittedly confusing. You might be expecting a coefficient matrix such as you would get from B=X\Y. But mvregress requires that you set up X as a cell array to do this. A benefit of that is that you have more flexibility, so for example you can constrain some coefficients to be the same across the columns of Y. But there is a cost of a less-than-simple interface. Rest assured that it is multivariate, in that it takes into account covariance across the Y columns.

You want B to be a P-by-Q matrix. If you set things up properly, B will be a (P*Q)-by-1 vector with all the same elements that you want. You can reshape it to P-by-Q.

Let me know if the references the cyclist points out aren't sufficient to explain how to set up X. I'm hoping we will make mvregress simpler in the future.

Anoosh
on 23 Jan 2016

the cyclist
on 23 Jan 2016

@Anoosh:

Although this is a perfectly sensible place to ask this question, you won't actually get much attention from a comment buried in a 3-year-old thread.

I suggest you ask a new question. If you can actually attach files with your data and code, that will help people diagnose your issue.

Sign in to comment.

Sign in to answer this question.

Opportunities for recent engineering grads.

Apply Today
## 2 Comments

## Direct link to this comment

https://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/answers/67399-mvregress-does-not-do-multivariate-linear-regression#comment_399633

⋮## Direct link to this comment

https://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/answers/67399-mvregress-does-not-do-multivariate-linear-regression#comment_399633

## Direct link to this comment

https://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/answers/67399-mvregress-does-not-do-multivariate-linear-regression#comment_399640

⋮## Direct link to this comment

https://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/answers/67399-mvregress-does-not-do-multivariate-linear-regression#comment_399640

Sign in to comment.