Problem 105. How to find the position of an element in a vector without using the find function
Solution Stats
Problem Comments

8 Comments
not set up right  only one input provided
Ditto Will's comment
Please corect it or remove it.
Acting as an Admin, I tried to clean up the problem. I am rescoring, but naturally some of the "correct" answers will now fail.
Lots of "solutions" use the find function. I don't get it  what's the point of doing the problem if you ignore the key instruction?
May you please add this (or something similar) to the test suite:
% Test for find usage
fid = fopen(which('test'), 'r');
c = onCleanup(@()fclose(fid));
tline = fgetl(fid);
while ischar(tline),
if strfind(tline,'find'),
error('Don''t use find');
end
tline = fgetl(fid);
end
This should work fine after you've renamed your function.
there should be more test suite. such as x =[1 2 3;4 5 6;7 8 9];y =5;then the output is [2,2]; x = [1 2 2 3]; y =2;then the output is [2;2];
The test suite needs to be very restrictive here, the amount of trivial solutions is alarming. Yan
Solution Comments

1 Comment
This user (mohamed elbesealy) appears to have gamed the system, with fraudulent "likes" of this unremarkable solution submitted by 'sockpuppet' accounts. —DIV

1 Comment
No, this solution is not expected.
"without using the find function"

1 Comment
The idea to write a code without using the predefined function is a bit weird. So my solution is deliberately cheating.

1 Comment
Could you explain to me what's the function of '@' in your solution ?

1 Comment
It is funny that this
feval(@eval, '[~, ans] = max(x==y);')
has smaller size than this
[~, ans] = max(x==y);

1 Comment
...I cheated to find out if you really were checking the conditions. Which you aren't. Shame.

1 Comment
I know, I know, sorry about this...

1 Comment
cheater

1 Comment
What about the detail "without using the find function"?!

1 Comment
how does this solve the problem? assert(strfind~=find)=false.

2 Comments

1 Comment
What about the detail "without using the find function"?!

1 Comment
What about the detail "without using the find function"?!

1 Comment
What about the detail "without using the find function"?!
Problem Recent Solvers2562
Suggested Problems

Back to basics 13  Input variables
238 Solvers

Convert a numerical matrix into a cell array of strings
933 Solvers

Getting the absolute index from a matrix
220 Solvers

311 Solvers

Sum of odd numbers in a matrix
398 Solvers
Problem Tags
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!