Why is my step response going down instead of up?

10 views (last 30 days)
I am trying to plot the step response of a 6th order ITAE system as part of a homework assignment. One of the criteria is to use a undamped natural frequency that is 2 times of one that i used in a previous part of the problem. When I plot the step response, the plot is going down, which seems off.
I am wondering if there is a problem with my code and am hoping somebody can point out my error. My code is segmented into part i), ii) and iii). Part iii) is where I deal with the 6th order ITAE.
Thanks in advance
% i) Calculate the undamped natural frequency and damping ratio required
% for a standard generic second-order system to achieve (assuming unit step input).
% WHAT are the associated sytem eigenvalues? Plot the unit step response
% for the result and demonstrate how well the design criteria are
% met (normalize your output to ensure the final value is 1.0).
% Display the resulting rise time, peak time, settling time, and percent
% overshoot on your graph. USE Percent overshoot = 3, settling time=3
% Values used from chapter 1.
% Mass values
m1 = 1;
m2 = 2;
m3 = 3;
% Spring Coefficients
k1 = 1;
k2 = 2;
k3 = 3;
k4 = 4;
% Damping Coefficients
c1 = 1;
c2 = 2;
c3 = 3;
c4 = 4;
% A, B, C and D matrix generated from chapter 1.
A = [0 0 0 1 0 0;
0 0 0 0 1 0;
0 0 0 0 0 1;
((-1)*((k1+k2)/m1)) (k2/m1) 0 ((-1)*((c1+c2)/m1)) (c2/m1) 0;
(k2/m2) ((-1)*((k2+k3)/m2)) (k3/m3) (c2/m2) ((-1)*((c2+c3)/m2)) (c3/m2);
0 (k3/m3) ((-1)*((k3+k4)/m3)) 0 (c3/m3) ((-1)*((c3+c4)/m3))];
B = [0 0 0;
0 0 0;
0 0 0;
(1/m1) 0 0;
0 (1/m2) 0;
0 0 (1/m3)];
C = [1 0 0 0 0 0;
0 1 0 0 0 0;
0 0 1 0 0 0];
D = [0 0 0;
0 0 0;
0 0 0];
sys_1 = ss(A,B,C,D);
% Specifying percent overshoot (3%) and settling time (3s):
PO = 3;
ts = 3;
% Finding damping ratio and undamped natural frequency
term = pi^2 + log(PO/100)^2;
zeta = log(PO/100)/sqrt(term) % Damping ratio
wn = 4/(zeta*ts) % Natural frequency from settling time and zeta.
% Setting up generic desired second order system
num1 = wn^2;
den1 = [1 2*zeta*wn wn^2];
% Desired control law eignevalues
DesEig1 = roots(den1)
Des1 = tf(num1,den1) % Create desired systems from num2 and den2
% Plotting
figure();
td = [0:0.01:40.0];
step(Des1,td);
% We will utilize this to display desired info. Commented out for now
stepinfo(Des1);
%% Part ii) Augment desired second order system eigenvalues
% Need 4 additional eigenvalues since this is a 6th order system
% The first additional eigenvalue was chosen to be 10 times the
% real part of the eigenvalue obtained in part i)
DesEig3 = real(DesEig1(1))*10; % We add the real() to isolate real part from complex number
DesEig4 = DesEig3-1;
DesEig5 = DesEig4-1;
DesEig6 = DesEig5-1;
%% Part iii) Computate the ITAE 6th-order coefficients & Eigenvalues.
% Undamped natural freq is 2 times that of part i).
% Plot the 6th order ITAE and the augmented 6th order step response with
% the dominant second order step response of part i).
w_itae = wn*2
num_itae = (w_itae)^2; % NEEDS TO BE 2 TIMES w used in part i). Question is which w? or all?
% 6th order ITAE
den_itae = [1 3.25*wn 6.6*wn^2 8.6*wn^3 7.45*wn^4 3.95*wn^5 wn^6];
% Finding Eigenvalues from ITAE characteristic polynomial
DesEig_Itae = roots(den_itae)
Itae_tf = tf(num_itae,den_itae);
figure();
td = [0:0.01:60.0];
step(Itae_tf,td);

Accepted Answer

Pat Gipper
Pat Gipper on 28 Nov 2021
I would focus on your equation for zeta on line 60. It is resulting in a negative value (negative damping=bad!) which gives unstable eigenvalues in the remainder of your code.
  1 Comment
Justin Goh
Justin Goh on 29 Nov 2021
Thank you so much. My textbook even had absolute values around the zeta.

Sign in to comment.

More Answers (0)

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!