Non-linearity errors and zero-crossing errors while training a RL Agent

A few days ago I posted a question about the training of an agent applied to the control of a nonlinear model of a three-degree-of-freedom aircraft. During training, randomly, I get this warning

The output port signal type of 'RL_Training_TECS_Model/Environment System/State Propagator/Forces, Moments, 3DoF/Aerodynamic Coefficients, 3DoF/Datcom Aerodynamic Model' is real (non-complex), however, the evaluated output is complex. Consider setting the 'OutputSignalType' to complex

followed by this error

Error using rl.internal.train.OffPolicyTrainer/run_internal_/nestedRunEpisode (line 284)

An error occurred while running the simulation for model 'RL_Training_TECS_Model' with the following RL agent blocks:

RL_Training_TECS_Model/RL TECS Alt Hold

Error in rl.internal.train.OffPolicyTrainer/run_internal_ (line 351)

out = nestedRunEpisode(policy);

Error in rl.internal.train.OffPolicyTrainer/run_ (line 40)

result = run_internal_(this);

Error in rl.internal.train.Trainer/run (line 8)

result = run_(this);

Error in rl.internal.trainmgr.OnlineTrainingManager/run_ (line 112)

trainResult = run(trainer);

Error in rl.internal.trainmgr.TrainingManager/run (line 4)

result = run_(this);

Error in rl.agent.AbstractAgent/train (line 86)

trainingResult = run(tm);

Caused by:

Error using rl.env.internal.reportSimulinkSimError (line 29)

Simulink will stop the simulation of model 'RL_Training_TECS_Model' because the 1 zero crossing signal(s) identified below caused 1000 consecutive zero crossing events in time interval between 7.6446467665241798e-11 and 7.6446467670045701e-11.

-------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------

Number of consecutive zero-crossings: 1000

Zero-crossing signal name : SwitchCond

Block type: Switch

Block path : 'RL_Training_TECS_Model/Environment System/State Propagator/Forces, Moments, 3DoF/Aerodynamic Coefficients, 3DoF/Switch'

-------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------

or this one

Error using rl.internal.train.OffPolicyTrainer/run_internal_/nestedRunEpisode (line 284)

An error occurred while running the simulation for model 'RL_Training_TECS_Model' with the following RL agent blocks:

RL_Training_TECS_Model/RL TECS Alt Hold

Error in rl.internal.train.OffPolicyTrainer/run_internal_ (line 351)

out = nestedRunEpisode(policy);

Error in rl.internal.train.OffPolicyTrainer/run_ (line 40)

result = run_internal_(this);

Error in rl.internal.train.Trainer/run (line 8)

result = run_(this);

Error in rl.internal.trainmgr.OnlineTrainingManager/run_ (line 112)

trainResult = run(trainer);

Error in rl.internal.trainmgr.TrainingManager/run (line 4)

result = run_(this);

Error in rl.agent.AbstractAgent/train (line 86)

trainingResult = run(tm);

Caused by:

Error using rl.env.internal.reportSimulinkSimError (line 29)

Solver encountered an error while simulating model 'RL_Training_TECS_Model' at time 1.140683144978552e-08 and cannot continue. Please check the model for errors.

Error using rl.env.internal.reportSimulinkSimError (line 29)

Nonlinear iteration is not converging with step size reduced to hmin (4.05252E-23) at time 1.14068E-08. Try reducing the minimum step size and/or relax the relative error tolerance.

At the start of each episode, the reset function trims the aircraft to a safe area I specify and then linearizes. What could these errors be due to?

Answer 1

[Maneet Kaur Bagga]

Hi,

I understand that you are encountering error during the training of your reinforcement learning agent for the non linear aircraft model. Please refer to the following as a possible workaround to debug and resolve the error:

1. Error in "Zero Crossing" and "Switch" block:

• Go to Model Settings > Solver > Zero crossing control and modify the zero crossing detection algorithm settings in Simulink.
• Re-evaluate switch block so that it does not create rapid oscillations leading to frequent zero crossings.

2. Nonlinear Solver Convergence

• Adjust the solver settings to help with convergence, increase the relative and absolute error tolerance and the minimum step size.
• The model should be stable so that it does not introduce high frequency dynamics or instability.

Please refer to the following File Exchenge link for further understanding:

https://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/fileexchange/87132-reinforcement-learning-for-control-of-non-linear-valves?s_tid=answers_rc2-2_p5_MLT

Hope this helps!

Answer 2

[Mxolisi]

Hi Maneet Kaur Bagga

I am actually getting the same error but it a bit tricky for me to follow your instruction:

Error using rl.internal.train.OffPolicyTrainer/run_internal_/nestedRunEpisode (line 284)

An error occurred while running the simulation for model 'RLmxolisifinal' with the following RL agent blocks:

RLmxolisifinal/RL Agent

Error in rl.internal.train.OffPolicyTrainer/run_internal_ (line 351)

out = nestedRunEpisode(policy);

Error in rl.internal.train.OffPolicyTrainer/run_ (line 40)

result = run_internal_(this);

Error in rl.internal.train.Trainer/run (line 8)

result = run_(this);

Error in rl.internal.trainmgr.OnlineTrainingManager/run_ (line 112)

trainResult = run(trainer);

Error in rl.internal.trainmgr.TrainingManager/run (line 4)

result = run_(this);

Error in rl.agent.AbstractAgent/train (line 86)

trainingResult = run(tm);

Caused by:

Error using rl.env.internal.reportSimulinkSimError (line 29)

Unable to find system or file 'rRLmxolisifinal'.