Solve Equation for w(t)
Show older comments
I need to solve the following equation to w(t). I just need the real part solution. w(t) = .....
All other variables are later given in a table so I can calculate different solutions.
I´m not able to solve this in a m.file?
It would be great if someone can help me. please
Thanks a lot
7 Comments
David Hill
on 30 Jan 2021
Show us your code.
Mario Braumüller
on 30 Jan 2021
Mario Braumüller
on 31 Jan 2021
Mario Braumüller
on 31 Jan 2021
I need to solve the following equation to w(t). I just need the real part solution. w(t) = .....
All other variables are later given in a table so I can calculate different solutions.
I´m not able to solve this in a m.file?
It would be great if someone can help me. please
Thanks a lot
Rik
on 28 Feb 2021
Deleted comments:
Hello, i tried it with the following code:
syms rho_w w(t) p_u d_0 D_0 l h_0 t kappa m_St m_w rho_L c_w A_Q v(t) h_d lambda zeta n
eqn = (rho_w / 2) * w(t)^2 + p_u == (rho_w / 2) * (d_0 / D_0)^4 * w(t)^2 + ((l - h_0) / (l - h_0 + (d_0 / D_0)^2 * w(t) * t))^kappa + (rho_w / (m_St + m_w - rho_w * (pi / 4) * d_0^2 * w(t) * t)) * (rho_w * (pi / 4) * d_0^2 * w(t)^2 - (rho_L / 2) * c_w * A_Q * v(t)^2) * (h_0 + h_d - (d_0 / D_0)^2 * w(t) * t) + (rho_w / 2) * (d_0 / D_0)^4 * w(t)^2 * (lambda * ((h_0 - (d_0 / D_0)^2 * w(t) * t) / D_0) + sum(zeta,i,1,n)) ;
solx = solve(eqn, w(t))
This equation is now to be solved for w (t), but under the condition that v (t) is known.
Rena Berman
on 6 May 2021
(Answers Dev) Restored edit
Answers (1)
syms rho_w w(t) p_u d_0 D_0 l h_0 t kappa m_St m_w rho_L c_w A_Q v(t) h_d lambda zeta n
syms sum_of_zeta
eqn = (rho_w / 2) * w(t)^2 + p_u == (rho_w / 2) * (d_0 / D_0)^4 * w(t)^2 + ((l - h_0) / (l - h_0 + (d_0 / D_0)^2 * w(t) * t))^kappa + (rho_w / (m_St + m_w - rho_w * (pi / 4) * d_0^2 * w(t) * t)) * (rho_w * (pi / 4) * d_0^2 * w(t)^2 - (rho_L / 2) * c_w * A_Q * v(t)^2) * (h_0 + h_d - (d_0 / D_0)^2 * w(t) * t) + (rho_w / 2) * (d_0 / D_0)^4 * w(t)^2 * (lambda * ((h_0 - (d_0 / D_0)^2 * w(t) * t) / D_0) + sum_of_zeta) ;
syms W V
eqnW = subs(eqn, w(t), W)
solw = solve(eqnW, W)
char(eqnW)
5 Comments
Walter Roberson
on 31 Jan 2021
If you work through the expression a bit, you will see that you have
in such a way that
is the roots of a polynomial of degree
. There will not be any explicit solution for such a polynomial unless κ is -4, -3, -2, -1, or 0.
is the roots of a polynomial of degree
Walter Roberson
on 31 Jan 2021
Look at the last line of your equation. It has an expression in
multiplied by an expression in w(t) . Those multiplied together give an expression in
.
multiplied by an expression in w(t) . Those multiplied together give an expression in
.Now look at the denominator in the first term on the second line of the equation, and we see that there is a division by w(t) . Clearing that division requires multiplying both sides by the denominiator, which is going to take that
term and multiply it by a w(t) term, getting a
term.
term and multiply it by a w(t) term, getting a
term.Now look at the last term on the first line and see that there is a w(t) in the denominator, and that the whole thing is raised to κ . Clearing out that division would require multiplying everything by the denominator, so you get another
being multiplied by the
giving us a polynomial in
.
giving us a polynomial in
.According to the Abel-Ruffini theorem, there are no closed form solutions for all polynomials of degree 5 or higher: you get lucky with some of them, but not in general. So you cannot count on their being a solution unless that
which requires
to be able to expect a formula for a solution.
which requires
to be able to expect a formula for a solution.
Walter Roberson
on 1 Feb 2021
No, it is not possible for that equation to have 3 complex solutions and one real solution, not unless at least one of the coefficients are complex valued. Any polynomial system that has real-valued coefficients always has an even number of real-valued roots and the complex roots are always complex conjugates. Another other combination of roots multiplies out to have complex coefficients.
James Tursa
on 6 May 2021
"... always has an even number of real-valued roots ..."
should read
"... always has an even number of complex-valued roots ..."
Walter Roberson
on 7 May 2021
James is correct, I mis-typed before.
Categories
Find more on Symbolic Math Toolbox in Help Center and File Exchange
Community Treasure Hunt
Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!
Start Hunting!