File Exchange

## K-Best Assignment Algorithm

version 1.0.0.0 (4.29 KB) by Eric Trautmann

### Eric Trautmann (view profile)

Implementation of Murty's algorithm for a ranked list of best assignment solutions.

Updated 23 Mar 2011

This implementation is based on the 1968 Murty algorithm for finding a ranked list of the best assignments for an arbitrary cost matrix.

This algorithm uses a user-supplied assignment algorithm, such as the Munkres (Hungarian) algorithm or the JV algorithm to obtain an arbitrary number of best assignment solutions.

Implementations of Munkres and JV algorithms by Yi Cao can be found here:

### Cite As

Eric Trautmann (2019). K-Best Assignment Algorithm (https://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/fileexchange/30837-k-best-assignment-algorithm), MATLAB Central File Exchange. Retrieved .

Tianli Ma

### Tianli Ma (view profile)

Fernando Iglesias

### Fernando Iglesias (view profile)

It does not work properly. Even if you set k=1 and the optimal assignment function provided is correct, the function k_best_assign does not return the correct optimal assignment.

Matthew

Junk code.

Nick

### Nick (view profile)

In my program I choose the JV algorithm as the opt_fun in your function.I think the "k_best_assign" main function has not any problems.But the subfunction "partition_node" is wrong.In the subfunction "partition_node",you classify the node_in matrix as three parts,"the fixed_assignments","the excluded_assignments","the tmp".Then input these three parts to the subfunction "calc_node_cost" to calculate the cost and the new [row col] matrix as the next cycle input.But If we take a good look at the code of the subfunction "partition_node",we will find some logic problems.In the progress of calculate cost,firstly you use the "fixed_assignments" to make summation of some previous fixed data.Then you use the "inf" to replace these data,and calculate the cost again.At last,you add up the summation of some previous fixed data and cost,and think the result is the cost.But you are wrong,because except some special situations,the cost you calculated is "inf" for in your function the fixed_assignments has changed some entire rows and entire columns into "inf" .So,most of the costs you calculate is "inf".Therefore,your comparing all the cost to find the minimum cost is meaningless.

Dmitri Kamenetsky

### Dmitri Kamenetsky (view profile)

Does this code work correctly? I am running

cost_mat = magic(5);
k = 5;
optfun = @munkres;
assignment_list = k_best_assign(cost_mat,k,opt_fun);

The resulting assignment_list has 5 assignments that are all exactly the same, namely [1 1; 1 2; 1 3; 1 4; 1 5] with a cost of 15.

##### MATLAB Release Compatibility
Created with R2010b
Compatible with any release
##### Platform Compatibility
Windows macOS Linux