Over the years I have looked at many Shortest Path FEX submissions. Most,if not all of these, were implementations of Dijkstra's algorithm for dense adjacency matrices.
These submissions had very limited usefulness because most real graph problems are sparse and most can be solved much more efficiently by a variant of the Bellman-Ford-Moore (BFM) algorithm which predates Dijkstra by 4 or 5 years. Better still, BFM is robust in the sense that it can handle negative arc-weights and detect and find negative cycles. Dijkstra cannot do this and for this reason is not considered robust.
It was for these reasons and others that I decided to (try) to write the simplest possible Matlab function for shortest paths. This forced me to use the simplest possible data structures to represent the problem and its solution, in Matlab: the graph G is represented by a list of m arcs (head, tail, weight) or (u,v,duv); the solution is represented by a tree p which is an n-vector of parent "pointers"; the n-vector D is the shortest path distances. Thus the path from node u to the root r is u,p(u),p(p(u)), ... , p(r). The length of this shortest path is D(u). We can see that the space used is S = No. of arcs = m (nnz) + 2*n fixed-sized boxes. You can't get lower than that.
The latest version of the notes on this algorithm is available at:
Derek O'Connor (2020). The Bellman-Ford-Moore Shortest Path Algorithm (https://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/fileexchange/38129-the-bellman-ford-moore-shortest-path-algorithm), MATLAB Central File Exchange. Retrieved .
How can I use the code to detect negative cycles in the graph. Could you provide an example code ?
Do I understand correctly when I say that your function is only capable of computing the shortest path between a root and all other nodes. I am looking for a function that efficiently computes shortest paths between all nodes in a subset of the nodes of the whole graph.
Do I understand your code correctly when I say the following:
- I would have to call the function multiple times (for each root). It is not possible to specify r as a vector of roots? In other words, this algorithm does not save any info when you have to compute path from multiple roots.
- All computation spent on shortest paths to nodes that I do not need is lost. Is this really necessary (i.e. inherent to the Bellman-Ford algorithm) or could this could become faster if it is adapted to the situation I need it for?
Thank you very much for your reply.
Derek, I sent you an email outlining the real problem data/context etc.
I look forward to your reply!
@none Thanks for your compliments.
I would be grateful if you would post or send me your results for these REAL problems.
For example, I have not been able to find the official optimum solutions to the problems. This makes me uneasy.
My mistake! Yes I can see you have written it in.
Excellent algo that works straight out of the box.
This file is not there because I did not have room for the larger files on my website. I pointed this out at the start of TestBFNOTMaps.m
All the USA files are available here:
I try to run TestBFNOTMaps.m and get the error
Error using load
Unable to read file spusaNE: No such file or directory.
where is this file? Not in the zip file.
I have corrected an error in BFMSpathOT.m The two variables 'head' and 'tail' were switched which resulted in the directed arcs of the network being reversed.
OLD: [m,n,p,D,tail,head,W] = Initialize(spG);
NEW: [m,n,p,D,head,tail,W] = Initialize(spG);
This means that the old version gave the wrong answers [p D]. However, this change does not affect the analysis and running time of the algorithm.
The updated Matlab function BFMSpathOT.m can be found at:
I have an important update to this submission which corrects an error but the UPDATE process fails each time I use it.
Added a Scribd link for the notes on this algorithm.
Updated notes and results of tests.
Added an 11-page paper of notes and two test functions: one for random networks and one for real road networks
Minor code modification
Added a minor note.
Eliminated irrelevant comments
Corrected minor typos