MATLAB Answers

ind2sub doesn't work

19 views (last 30 days)
Egor
Egor on 18 Jul 2014
Commented: Egor on 18 Jul 2014
Check it out:
>> A = zeros(3);
>> A(2,3) = 1
A =
0 0 0
0 0 1
0 0 0
>> tmp = A'
tmp =
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 1 0
>> [maxVal, maxInd] = max(tmp(:))
maxVal =
1
maxInd =
6
And now the WTF comes:
>> ind2sub(size(tmp), maxInd)
ans =
6
>> ind2sub(maxInd, size(tmp))
ans =
3 3
Seems like function is dead.

  0 Comments

Sign in to comment.

Accepted Answer

Alfonso Nieto-Castanon
Alfonso Nieto-Castanon on 18 Jul 2014
Edited: Alfonso Nieto-Castanon on 18 Jul 2014
You are funny.
ind2sub reshapes the siz first argument to match the number of output variables used (in your case a single output argument), so that the resulting subscripts suffice to fully index the original elements. In your case:
ind2sub(size(tmp), maxInd)
is just the same as:
ind2sub(numel(tmp), maxInd)

  1 Comment

Egor
Egor on 18 Jul 2014
thanks! I am really funny :)

Sign in to comment.

More Answers (2)

Matt J
Matt J on 18 Jul 2014
>> [i,j]=ind2sub(size(tmp), maxInd)
i =
3
j =
2

  1 Comment

Egor
Egor on 18 Jul 2014
thanks!

Sign in to comment.


James Tursa
James Tursa on 18 Jul 2014
Edited: James Tursa on 18 Jul 2014
The typical use of ind2sub in your case is to request two outputs:
[I J] = ind2sub(size(tmp), maxInd)
I =
3
J =
2
Which is the correct row & column for the index passed to the function.
What you have done is this:
ind2sub(size(tmp), maxInd) --> ind2sub([3 3], 6)
So you have asked a function that is typically expecting to produce two outputs (the number of elements in the first argument) to instead produce only one output. It did the only reasonable thing given the way you called it (less than the expected number of outputs) ... it returned the single linear index into your single output variable.
The next thing you did was this:
ind2sub(maxInd, size(tmp)) --> ind2sub(6,[3 3])
So you have told the function the dimension of the matrix is 1x6 and you have two indexes you want to convert to subscripts ... a 3 and a 3. So it did the correct conversion. Three elements into a 1x6 matrix yields the subscript 3. That's again a correct result.
You should probably re-read the doc on ind2sub, particularly the section on "Effects of Returning Fewer Outputs".

  1 Comment

Egor
Egor on 18 Jul 2014
thank you! I read through 'help' function, so expected it always to return 2D value.

Sign in to comment.

Sign in to answer this question.

Tags