1 vote

Hello everyone,
I create a fuzzy tree (aggregated structure) in Matlab and I have an error which I hope to be supported.
My fuzzy tree has 3 fuzzy models (nd_fis, lk_fis, Aggfis3). nd_fis is the node fis and it has 2 inputs: HC and EC. lk_fis is link_fis and it has 3 input: LQI,Mobility and PFI. Outputs of nd_fis and lk_fis are Inputs of fis3.
However, when I run it, the error is “Error using fistree/set.Connections
Specified connections include unrecognized FIS name "Aggfis3".
Error in fistree (line 293)
obj.Connections = p.Results.Connections;
What's wrong please, following is the code with the line underlined is where the error appears:
// Fuzzy model 1
nd_fis = mamfis('Name',"FNode");
nd_fis = addInput(nd_fis,[0 7],'Name',"HC");
nd_fis = addMF(nd_fis,"HC","trapmf",[0 0 1 2],'Name',"Short");
nd_fis = addMF(nd_fis,"HC","trapmf",[1 2 3 4],'Name',"Medium");
nd_fis = addMF(nd_fis,"HC","trapmf",[3 5 7 7],'Name',"Long");
nd_fis = addInput(nd_fis,[0 250],'Name',"EC");
nd_fis = addMF(nd_fis,"EC","trapmf",[0 0 50 100],'Name',"Low");
nd_fis = addMF(nd_fis,"EC","trapmf",[50 100 150 200],'Name',"Moderate");
nd_fis = addMF(nd_fis,"EC","trapmf",[150 200 250 250],'Name',"High");
nd_fis = addOutput(nd_fis,[0 100],'Name',"NS");
nd_fis = addMF(nd_fis,"NS","trimf",[0 25 45],'Name',"Low");
nd_fis = addMF(nd_fis,"NS","trimf",[25 45 75],'Name',"Medium");
nd_fis = addMF(nd_fis,"NS","trimf",[50 75 100],'Name',"High");
nd_rulelist = ["if HC is Short and EC is Low then NS is High";
"if HC is Short and EC is Moderate then NS is Medium";
"if HC is Short and EC is High then NS is Low";
"if HC is Medium and EC is Low then NS is High";
"if HC is Medium and EC is Moderate then NS is High";
"if HC is Medium and EC is High then NS is Medium";
"if HC is Long and EC is Low then NS is High";
"if HC is Long and EC is Moderate then NS is Medium";
"if HC is Long and EC is High then NS is Low"];
FINALnd_fis = addRule(nd_fis,nd_rulelist);
// Fuzzy model 2
lk_fis = mamfis('Name',"FLink");
lk_fis = addInput(lk_fis,[0 7],'Name',"LQI");
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis,"LQI","trapmf",[0 0 1 2],'Name',"Fair");
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis,"LQI","trapmf",[1 2 3 4],'Name',"Good");
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis,"LQI","trapmf",[3 5 7 7],'Name',"Excellent");
lk_fis = addInput(lk_fis,[0 20],'Name',"Mobility");
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis,"Mobility","trapmf",[0 0 2 6],'Name',"Slow");
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis,"Mobility","trapmf",[4 7 11 14],'Name',"Medium");
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis,"Mobility","trapmf",[12 18 20 20],'Name',"Fast");
lk_fis = addInput(lk_fis,[0 100],'Name',"PFI");
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis,"PFI","trapmf",[0 0 2 40],'Name',"Low");
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis,"PFI","trapmf",[30 45 55 70],'Name',"Medium");
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis,"PFI","trapmf",[60 80 100 100],'Name',"High");
lk_fis = addOutput(lk_fis,[0 100],'Name',"LS");
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis,"LS","trimf",[0 25 45],'Name',"Low");
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis,"LS","trimf",[25 45 75],'Name',"Medium");
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis,"LS","trimf",[50 75 100],'Name',"High");
lk_rulelist = ["if LQI is Excellent and Mobility is Slow and PFI is High then LS is High";
"if LQI is Excellent and Mobility is Slow and PFI is Medium then LS is High";
"if LQI is Excellent and Mobility is Slow and PFI is Low then LS is High";
"if LQI is Excellent and Mobility is Medium and PFI is High then LS is High";
"if LQI is Excellent and Mobility is Medium and PFI is Medium then LS is High";
"if LQI is Excellent and Mobility is Medium and PFI is Low then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Excellent and Mobility is Fast and PFI is High then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Excellent and Mobility is Fast and PFI is Medium then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Excellent and Mobility is Fast and PFI is Low then LS is Low";
"if LQI is Good and Mobility is Slow and PFI is High then LS is High";
"if LQI is Good and Mobility is Slow and PFI is Medium then LS is High";
"if LQI is Good and Mobility is Slow and PFI is Low then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Good and Mobility is Medium and PFI is High then LS is High";
"if LQI is Good and Mobility is Medium and PFI is Medium then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Good and Mobility is Medium and PFI is Low then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Good and Mobility is Fast and PFI is High then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Good and Mobility is Fast and PFI is Medium then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Good and Mobility is Fast and PFI is Low then LS is Low";
"if LQI is Fair and Mobility is Slow and PFI is High then LS is High";
"if LQI is Fair and Mobility is Slow and PFI is Medium then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Fair and Mobility is Slow and PFI is Low then LS is Low";
"if LQI is Fair and Mobility is Medium and PFI is High then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Fair and Mobility is Medium and PFI is Medium then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Fair and Mobility is Medium and PFI is Low then LS is Low";
"if LQI is Fair and Mobility is Fast and PFI is High then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Fair and Mobility is Fast and PFI is Medium then LS is Low";
"if LQI is Fair and Mobility is Fast and PFI is Low then LS is Low"
];
FINALlk_fis = addRule(lk_fis,lk_rulelist);
//Fuzzy model 3
Aggfis3 = mamfis('Name','RoutingDecision');
Aggfis3 = addInput(Aggfis3,[0 100],'Name',"LS");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3,"LS","trimf",[0 25 45],'Name',"Low");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3,"LS","trimf",[25 45 75],'Name',"Medium");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3,"LS","trimf",[50 75 100],'Name',"High");
Aggfis3 = addInput(Aggfis3,[0 100],'Name',"NS");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3,"NS","trimf",[0 25 45],'Name',"Low");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3,"NS","trimf",[25 45 75],'Name',"Medium");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3,"NS","trimf",[50 75 100],'Name',"High");
Aggfis3.Outputs(1).Name = "RD";
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3,"RD","trimf",[0 12 24],'Name',"VL");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3,"RD","trimf",[12 24 26],'Name',"L");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3,"RD","trimf",[24 36 48],'Name',"ML");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3,"RD","trimf",[36 48 60],'Name',"M");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3,"RD","trimf",[48 60 72],'Name',"MH");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3,"RD","trimf",[60 72 84],'Name',"H");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3,"RD","trimf",[72 84 100],'Name',"VH");
rulefis3d = ["if NS is Low and LS is Low then RD is VL";
"if NS is Low and LS is Medium then RD is L";
"if NS is Low and LS is High then RD is ML";
"if NS is Medium and LS is Low then RD is ML";
"if NS is Medium and LS is Medium,then RD is M";
"if NS is Medium and LS is High then RD is MH";
"if NS is High and LS is Low then RD is MH";
"if NS is High and LS is Medium then RD is H";
"if NS is High and LS is High then RD is VH"];
Aggfis3 = addRule(Aggfis3,rulefis3d);
con1 = ["FNode/NS" "Aggfis3/NS"];
con2 = ["FLink/LS" "Aggfis3/LS"];
aggTree = fistree([FINALnd_fis FINALlk_fis Aggfis3],[con1;con2]);
aggTree.FIS(3) = addRule(aggTree.FIS(3), rulefis3d)

Sign in to answer this question.

 Accepted Answer

Sam Chak
Sam Chak on 1 Aug 2023
Ran in:

2 votes

Ran in:
HI @Layla Mohammad
Please check this out and see if these MFs, Surfaces, and the FIS Tree are what you are expecting.
% Fuzzy model 1
nd_fis = mamfis('Name', "FNode");
nd_fis = addInput(nd_fis, [0 7], 'Name', "HC");
nd_fis = addMF(nd_fis, "HC", "trapmf", [0 0 1 2], 'Name', "Short" );
nd_fis = addMF(nd_fis, "HC", "trapmf", [1 2 3 4], 'Name', "Medium");
nd_fis = addMF(nd_fis, "HC", "trapmf", [3 5 7 7], 'Name', "Long" );
nd_fis = addInput(nd_fis, [0 250], 'Name', "EC");
nd_fis = addMF(nd_fis, "EC", "trapmf", [ 0 0 50 100], 'Name', "Low" );
nd_fis = addMF(nd_fis, "EC", "trapmf", [ 50 100 150 200], 'Name', "Moderate");
nd_fis = addMF(nd_fis, "EC", "trapmf", [150 200 250 250], 'Name', "High" );
nd_fis = addOutput(nd_fis, [0 100], 'Name', "NS");
nd_fis = addMF(nd_fis, "NS", "trimf", [ 0 25 45], 'Name', "Low" );
nd_fis = addMF(nd_fis, "NS", "trimf", [25 45 75], 'Name', "Medium");
nd_fis = addMF(nd_fis, "NS", "trimf", [50 75 100], 'Name', "High" );
nd_rulelist = ["if HC is Short and EC is Low then NS is High";
"if HC is Short and EC is Moderate then NS is Medium";
"if HC is Short and EC is High then NS is Low";
"if HC is Medium and EC is Low then NS is High";
"if HC is Medium and EC is Moderate then NS is High";
"if HC is Medium and EC is High then NS is Medium";
"if HC is Long and EC is Low then NS is High";
"if HC is Long and EC is Moderate then NS is Medium";
"if HC is Long and EC is High then NS is Low"];
nd_fis = addRule(nd_fis, nd_rulelist); % <--- change in this line
figure(1)
tiledlayout(2,2);
nexttile
plotmf(nd_fis, 'input', 1)
nexttile
plotmf(nd_fis, 'input', 2)
nexttile
plotmf(nd_fis, 'output', 1)
nexttile
opt = gensurfOptions('NumGridPoints', 21);
gensurf(nd_fis, opt)
% Fuzzy model 2
lk_fis = mamfis('Name', "FLink");
lk_fis = addInput(lk_fis, [0 7], 'Name', "LQI");
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis, "LQI", "trapmf", [0 0 1 2], 'Name', "Fair" );
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis, "LQI", "trapmf", [1 2 3 4], 'Name', "Good" );
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis, "LQI", "trapmf", [3 5 7 7], 'Name', "Excellent");
lk_fis = addInput(lk_fis, [0 20], 'Name',"Mobility");
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis, "Mobility", "trapmf", [ 0 0 2 6], 'Name', "Slow" );
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis, "Mobility", "trapmf", [ 4 7 11 14], 'Name', "Medium");
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis, "Mobility", "trapmf", [12 18 20 20], 'Name', "Fast" );
lk_fis = addInput(lk_fis, [0 100], 'Name', "PFI");
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis, "PFI", "trapmf", [ 0 0 2 40], 'Name', "Low" );
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis, "PFI", "trapmf", [30 45 55 70], 'Name', "Medium");
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis, "PFI", "trapmf", [60 80 100 100], 'Name', "High" );
lk_fis = addOutput(lk_fis, [0 100], 'Name', "LS");
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis, "LS", "trimf", [ 0 25 45], 'Name', "Low" );
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis, "LS", "trimf", [25 45 75], 'Name', "Medium");
lk_fis = addMF(lk_fis, "LS", "trimf", [50 75 100], 'Name', "High" );
lk_rulelist = ["if LQI is Excellent and Mobility is Slow and PFI is High then LS is High";
"if LQI is Excellent and Mobility is Slow and PFI is Medium then LS is High";
"if LQI is Excellent and Mobility is Slow and PFI is Low then LS is High";
"if LQI is Excellent and Mobility is Medium and PFI is High then LS is High";
"if LQI is Excellent and Mobility is Medium and PFI is Medium then LS is High";
"if LQI is Excellent and Mobility is Medium and PFI is Low then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Excellent and Mobility is Fast and PFI is High then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Excellent and Mobility is Fast and PFI is Medium then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Excellent and Mobility is Fast and PFI is Low then LS is Low";
"if LQI is Good and Mobility is Slow and PFI is High then LS is High";
"if LQI is Good and Mobility is Slow and PFI is Medium then LS is High";
"if LQI is Good and Mobility is Slow and PFI is Low then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Good and Mobility is Medium and PFI is High then LS is High";
"if LQI is Good and Mobility is Medium and PFI is Medium then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Good and Mobility is Medium and PFI is Low then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Good and Mobility is Fast and PFI is High then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Good and Mobility is Fast and PFI is Medium then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Good and Mobility is Fast and PFI is Low then LS is Low";
"if LQI is Fair and Mobility is Slow and PFI is High then LS is High";
"if LQI is Fair and Mobility is Slow and PFI is Medium then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Fair and Mobility is Slow and PFI is Low then LS is Low";
"if LQI is Fair and Mobility is Medium and PFI is High then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Fair and Mobility is Medium and PFI is Medium then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Fair and Mobility is Medium and PFI is Low then LS is Low";
"if LQI is Fair and Mobility is Fast and PFI is High then LS is Medium";
"if LQI is Fair and Mobility is Fast and PFI is Medium then LS is Low";
"if LQI is Fair and Mobility is Fast and PFI is Low then LS is Low"];
lk_fis = addRule(lk_fis,lk_rulelist); % <--- change in this line
figure(2)
tiledlayout(2,2);
nexttile
plotmf(lk_fis, 'output', 1)
nexttile
opt = gensurfOptions('InputIndex', [1 2], 'NumGridPoints', 21);
gensurf(lk_fis, opt)
nexttile
opt = gensurfOptions('InputIndex', [1 3], 'NumGridPoints', 21);
gensurf(lk_fis, opt)
nexttile
opt = gensurfOptions('InputIndex', [2 3], 'NumGridPoints', 21);
gensurf(lk_fis, opt)
% Fuzzy model 3
Aggfis3 = mamfis('Name', 'RoutingDecision');
Aggfis3 = addInput(Aggfis3, [0 100], 'Name', "LS");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3, "LS", "trimf", [ 0 25 45], 'Name', "Low" );
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3, "LS", "trimf", [25 45 75], 'Name', "Medium");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3, "LS", "trimf", [50 75 100], 'Name', "High" );
Aggfis3 = addInput(Aggfis3, [0 100], 'Name', "NS");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3, "NS", "trimf", [ 0 25 45], 'Name', "Low" );
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3, "NS", "trimf", [25 45 75], 'Name', "Medium");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3, "NS", "trimf", [50 75 100], 'Name', "High" );
% Aggfis3.Outputs(1).Name = "RD";
Aggfis3 = addOutput(Aggfis3, [0 100], 'Name', "RD");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3, "RD", "trimf", [ 0 12 24], 'Name',"VL");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3, "RD", "trimf", [12 24 26], 'Name',"L" );
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3, "RD", "trimf", [24 36 48], 'Name',"ML");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3, "RD", "trimf", [36 48 60], 'Name',"M" );
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3, "RD", "trimf", [48 60 72], 'Name',"MH");
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3, "RD", "trimf", [60 72 84], 'Name',"H" );
Aggfis3 = addMF(Aggfis3, "RD", "trimf", [72 84 100], 'Name',"VH");
rulefis3d = ["if NS is Low and LS is Low then RD is VL";
"if NS is Low and LS is Medium then RD is L";
"if NS is Low and LS is High then RD is ML";
"if NS is Medium and LS is Low then RD is ML";
"if NS is Medium and LS is Medium then RD is M";
"if NS is Medium and LS is High then RD is MH";
"if NS is High and LS is Low then RD is MH";
"if NS is High and LS is Medium then RD is H";
"if NS is High and LS is High then RD is VH"];
Aggfis3 = addRule(Aggfis3, rulefis3d);
figure(3)
tiledlayout(2,2);
nexttile
plotmf(Aggfis3, 'input', 1)
nexttile
plotmf(Aggfis3, 'input', 2)
nexttile
plotmf(Aggfis3, 'output', 1)
nexttile
opt = gensurfOptions('NumGridPoints', 21);
gensurf(Aggfis3, opt)
aggTree = fistree([nd_fis lk_fis Aggfis3], []); % <--- change in this line
aggTree.Connections = [
"FNode/NS" "RoutingDecision/NS"; % <--- change in this line
"FLink/LS" "RoutingDecision/LS"]; % <--- change in this line
figure(4)
plotfis(aggTree)

7 Comments
Show 5 older comments Hide 5 older comments

Layla Mohammad
Layla Mohammad on 2 Aug 2023
Edited: Layla Mohammad on 2 Aug 2023
@Sam Chak
Yes thank you
one more question, how to save the result as fis?
As i have to convert the whole code as c code for simulation integration
Sam Chak
Sam Chak on 2 Aug 2023
Ran in:
Ran in:
You are welcome, @Layla Mohammad. If you find the solution on the FIS Tree issue helpful, please consider accepting ✔ and voting 👍 on the answer. Try the following for converting FIS tree into the homogeneous structure that is intended for code generation.
LaylaTreeData = getFISCodeGenerationData(aggTree)
https://www.mathworks.com/help/fuzzy/getfiscodegenerationdata.html
https://www.mathworks.com/help/coder/ug/homogeneous-vs-heterogeneous-cell-arrays.html
Also check MATLAB® Coder™: https://www.mathworks.com/help/coder/index.html
% Construct FIS Tree
aggTree = fistree([lk_fis nd_fis Aggfis3], []); % <--- change in this line
aggTree.Connections = [
"FLink/LS" "RoutingDecision/LS"; % <--- change in this line
"FNode/NS" "RoutingDecision/NS"]; % <--- change in this line
figure(4)
plotfis(aggTree)
aggTree
aggTree =
fistree with properties: Name: "fistreemodel" FIS: [1×3 mamfis] Connections: [2×2 string] Inputs: [5×1 string] Outputs: "RoutingDecision/RD" DisableStructuralChecks: 0 See 'getTunableSettings' method for parameter optimization.
% Converting FIS tree into the homogeneous structure
LaylaTreeData = getFISCodeGenerationData(aggTree)
LaylaTreeData = struct with fields:
FIS: {[1×1 struct] [1×1 struct] [1×1 struct]} Connections: {2×2 cell} Outputs: {'RoutingDecision/RD'} EvaluationFcn: [1×1 struct]
Layla Mohammad
Layla Mohammad on 5 Aug 2023
@Sam Chak Dear Sir
Would you please just send me an example on how to deal with the resulted structure from the last point!
I spent two days reading and trying, nothing was going well.
All i need is to convert the fistree to a file.FIS, Can i do that?
If not, then how to deal with the tree as FIS?
Thanks in advance
Sam Chak
Sam Chak on 5 Aug 2023
Ran in:
Ran in:
Hi @Layla Mohammad
The only way to save a FIS object to a .fis file is by using the writeFIS() command.
plotfis(aggTree)
aggTree
aggTree =
fistree with properties: Name: "fistreemodel" FIS: [1×3 mamfis] Connections: [2×2 string] Inputs: [5×1 string] Outputs: "RoutingDecision/RD" DisableStructuralChecks: 0 See 'getTunableSettings' method for parameter optimization.
writeFIS(aggTree, aggTree.Name)
Incorrect number or types of inputs or outputs for function 'writeFIS'.
LaylaTreeData = getFISCodeGenerationData(aggTree);
As you can see, it throws an error message. It appears that the Fuzzy Logic Toolbox does not currently have a direct built-in function to save the "FIS tree model" into a .fis file.
However, since the "FIS tree model" is already in the Workspace, it is possible to save "aggTree" or "LaylaTreeData" as a .MAT file. This way, the FIS tree model can be reloaded later for conversion to C code.
Layla Mohammad
Layla Mohammad on 5 Aug 2023
@Sam Chak Thank you very much for your efforts and reply, I already saved it as mat file.
The thing is i'm struggling in converting to c
Sam Chak
Sam Chak on 9 Aug 2023
Hi @Layla Mohammad
I recommend that you create a new post and tag it with 'MATLAB Coder' as the issue is related to generating C code from MATLAB code for the hardware platform.
Consider using the following title: "Generating C Code from FIS Tree Model using MATLAB Coder."
In your post, you can explain that you currently have a MATLAB algorithm (link to this thread) that generates the FIS Tree Model within the Workspace.
Layla Mohammad
Layla Mohammad on 9 Aug 2023
@Sam Chak Yes sure
Thank you very much for your reply and efforts

Sign in to comment.

More Answers (0)

Categories

Find more on Get Started with MATLAB in Help Center and File Exchange

Products

Release

R2023a

Tags

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!